Draft recap from day one-
Usually we see the “safe” Ted Thompson. Making sure he has lots of players so when guys do go belly up, he can point to others who worked. More picks is better, says Ted, and two next year is better than one this year almost all the time. However, in the first round, he tries to be careful. This year, however, we saw the aggressive side of Thompson, something I would like to see more of in the future.
Usually, in the first round, the one thing you don’t want to do is guarantee a bust. That’s what the Packers did by taking Justin Harrell two years ago, even though he had not played football for a couple of years, and had injury problems since high school. By picking a wide body who’s only trouble has been academically (though that is a symptom of other issues) and a linebacker with a big heart and good pedigree, the Packers were one of the winners in the NFL draft this year.
BJ Raji was a safe pick for Ted Thompson, and though he doesn’t usually pick safe, he did here. He could have gone with Michael Crabtree, the WR from Texas Tech who was still on the board, but by deciding that wasn’t a headache he wanted to deal with, he instead drafted the top player in the draft in a position of need, something you don’t normally get a chance to do unless you are in the top four or five. Raji could have gone as high as 4-5 and no one would have said that was an issue, so getting him at nine, where impact players end up being an every third year proposition, is pretty solid. My only worry about Raji is his motivation and work ethic. Scouting reports talk about his coaches diplomatically calling him a “gameday” player, meaning he didn’t like to practice. That won’t fly in Green Bay.
Clay Matthews III was another very solid pick, though some may ask if Thompson paid too much to get there. He moved up 15 spots to get a guy who is a late bloomer and hasn’t found his ceiling, much less hit it in his development. Matthews dad and grandfather both played in the league, his uncle is a hall of famer, so he knows what it takes to succeed in the league. He was a walk-on at USC, so he doesn’t have an air of entitlement about him. He played in the 3-4 for the Trojans, so knows the system, and is a weight room fiend, so no question on his work ethic.
Did the Packers pay too much? I don’t think so. If they got the guy they wanted, then the price doesn’t matter. They gave away their 2nd, which was a given, then their two thirds, and got a fifth in return. The difference between a 3rd and 5th rounder is moderate, but not so vast that it makes the trade lopsided. Throw in there the fact that one of the thirds was the one from the Jets that they got for Brett Favre, and you realize that Ted has been planning to move that pick all along. It was almost a free pick (trading instead of a retirement or cutting means they got something back at least) and anyone drafted in that slot would have never been able to live up to the “this is the guy they drafted for the Favre pick” responsibility.
Day two should be interesting- I expect at least two offensive linemen, probably a running back, and a couple of DB’s to go to the Packers. So far, though, after one day, I would say the bold Ted Thompson was right on the mark.